The secondary watch market has always rewarded the bold. But in 2026, it is rewarding only the chosen few — a tight cluster of brands and references capturing a disproportionate share of all resale value, while the rest of the market fights for scraps.
Understanding this dynamic isn’t just interesting. For anyone buying, selling or holding a luxury watch in Australia right now, it’s the difference between a smart decision and an expensive one.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
The data from multiple market intelligence providers — including EveryWatch, WatchCharts and Morgan Stanley — tells a remarkably consistent story heading into 2026.
The WatchCharts Overall Market Index rose +8.2% over the past year, but that headline figure conceals a sharp divide. Patek Philippe led all brands with appreciation of +16.2% over 12 months, while Rolex gained +7.9% and Audemars Piguet +3.4%. Meanwhile, the average watch outside these three still trades at a discount of 30% or more relative to its original retail price.
At the model level, the concentration is even starker. The Rolex Datejust and Daytona together generated an estimated €2.3 billion in combined secondary market transaction value in 2025 — from a single brand’s two models.
This is what analysts are calling “winner-takes-all” dynamics: a structural feature of the current market, not a temporary blip.
What’s Driving the Split?
Several forces are converging to entrench this bifurcation.
Retail price inflation is pushing buyers downstream. Major brands raised retail prices by an average of 7% in 2025, largely driven by the strength of the Swiss franc and rising gold prices. As new watch prices climb, savvy buyers are gravitating toward the secondary market for the same or better quality at a meaningful discount. This is especially pronounced for gold models, where rising raw material costs have established a firm pricing floor.
Demand is measurably expanding — but not evenly. In 2025, secondary market transaction volumes for Patek Philippe, Omega, Cartier, Vacheron Constantin and Tudor all grew by more than 20% year-on-year. That kind of expansion signals a maturing, legitimising market — not a speculative bubble. But growth is still concentrated in brands with strong recognition and proven collector narratives.
Supply constraints are amplifying price moves. For Rolex’s Daytona family — specifically the four generations of stainless steel references — secondary supply has been quietly declining even as demand holds firm. When supply contracts while demand expands, price appreciation becomes almost mechanical.
The post-COVID correction is over. From 2022 through 2024, the market was defined by the unwinding of pandemic-era speculation. That correction is done. What you are seeing now is organic, fundamentals-driven recovery — which tends to be more durable.
The Reference Level: Where the Real Action Is
Step down from brand-level data to individual references and the picture sharpens further.
The single best-performing reference of 2025 was the Rolex Daytona 116520 — the steel, pre-ceramic iteration — generating an estimated €50 million in secondary transaction value on tracked platforms alone. It occupies a rare sweet spot: modern enough for everyday wear, collectible enough to carry a premium, and scarce enough that supply never comfortably meets demand.
Beyond Rolex, the references performing strongest share a few common traits. They have strong collector narratives. They are visually coherent — their identity reads instantly. And they carry brand equity that transcends trends.
Notable performers from outside the Big Three include the Patek Nautilus 5726A (annual calendar in steel), Vacheron Constantin Overseas (unit sales and value both up over 50% year-on-year), Tudor Black Bay (secondary market value +21.8% in 2025), and Richard Mille RM 67 and RM 65 — proof that ultra-modern independent watchmaking still commands serious premiums when the brand story is compelling.
The Gen Z Factor: A Market-Shaping Shift
There is a generational undercurrent to these market dynamics that is easy to miss in the headline data.
Chrono24’s H1 2025 report documented a fourfold increase in Cartier’s share of Gen Z secondary market purchases over seven years — from 1.7% to 6.8% of all Gen Z transactions. More broadly, dress watch purchases by Gen Z buyers grew 44% between 2018 and 2025, compared to 29% across all other age groups. Twelve percent of all watches purchased by Gen Z today are dress watches — the highest share of any demographic.
This matters for the Australian market specifically. The country’s watch buyer is measurably younger than comparable markets in Europe. In Sydney and Melbourne, the fastest-growing cohort of secondary market buyers are Millennials and Gen Z — prioritising heritage, narrative, and sustainability over novelty. Brands that tell a compelling, authentic story are winning this demographic. Brands that don’t are finding it increasingly hard to compete.
What This Means for Australian Sellers Right Now
If you are holding a watch from Rolex, Patek Philippe, or Audemars Piguet — particularly a stainless steel sports or dress model in excellent condition with original box and papers — you are sitting on a piece of secondary market real estate that is actively appreciating.
If you are holding something from outside the recognised tier of strong performers, the picture is more nuanced. The secondary market is recovering broadly — 21 of 27 brands with an average price above $3,000 showed positive index performance in the 6 months to February 2026 — but the trajectory is gradual.
The most actionable insight from the current data: condition and provenance are amplifiers. Watches with original box, papers, and documented service history command a 10–30% premium over comparable pieces without documentation. In a market where authenticity and transparency are increasingly valued by educated buyers, this gap is widening.
The Bottom Line for 2026
The secondary watch market is recovering — but it is recovering unevenly, and for structurally sound reasons. Brand trust, collector narrative, supply scarcity, and documented provenance are the levers that matter. Understanding which side of that divide your watch sits on is the most important piece of market intelligence you can have.
Know what your watch is worth before you sell. Expert valuation backed by live dealer and auction data — no obligation, no pressure.
watchgaugehq.com/authenticate-and-value/
